Critique please.

topic posted Sun, May 6, 2007 - 9:28 PM by  Ther
I've been very busy but I was having a very silly night, last night.

Enjoy.

I Don’t Like Surprises

Forty years ago today,
We surprised you,
We feted you,
For your fortieth revolution around the sun.
You hated it.

I hope you’ve changed your mind.
Because, we are ready,
Hiding behind your sofa, your potted palm,
In your hallway closet.
Eighty years is worth celebrating.

We hear the door knob turn,
The latch release with a click,
A half of a beat behind the mantle clock producing the vestige of an echo.
We see your back.
You face the door as you push it shut.



“On your mark,
Get set,
Go!”



The look on your face is priceless
When you spin around.
Your right hand is on your chest,
Mouth splayed open like an upside-down boomerang,
Eyes like two lidless moons.
Then, you turn white as a sheet
And drop to the floor.

We rush out to the foyer,
To see why you’ve done what you’ve done.
What’s wrong?
Are you putting us on?
Scaring us for the surprise?
Getting even? You still hate surprise parties, do you?
Oh come on, get up.

But, wait-
I stand over you
And stare at your ashen face,
A face that, I must confess, I’ve never seen before.
You’re the wrong person.
We went to the wrong house.
posted by:
Ther
Washington
  • Re: Critique please.

    Sun, May 6, 2007 - 10:01 PM
    Wickedly funny, thanks Ther Alle you never surprise me with your excellence.
    • Re: Critique please.

      Mon, May 7, 2007 - 8:54 PM
      Thank you!
      • Re: Critique please.

        Fri, May 11, 2007 - 9:55 AM
        I like the situation... but I'm trying to put my finger on... something is keeping me from reading this as a poem.
        • Re: Critique please.

          Sat, May 12, 2007 - 11:06 AM
          "I like the situation... but I'm trying to put my finger on... something is keeping me from reading this as a poem."

          JM - you seem to like to put writings into one category or another.....? Or perhaps part of your critique process is to say, "This piece of writing is a <poem / short story / whatever>. How do I like it compared to other pieces from this genre?"

          If so, it's an interesting approach - I'm not sure I do that, but I bet lots of people do, and I never realized it till now.
          • Re: Critique please.

            Sat, May 12, 2007 - 2:18 PM
            Prose that reads as poetry, poetry that reads as prose, it's all good. Traditionally the boundaries were less broad than by today's standards, where one form easily morphs into another. My friend Kelley has for one of his goals in writing: (3) make no distinctions between short fiction, monologues, dialogues, scenes, and poetry. For me eliminating those distinction seems impossible to do completely when writing. I see each item as a tool to be used and made effective within a particular form. True, prose without adjectives appear lifeless, but their overuse in a piece of narrative can become annoying (for anyone but Collier).

            Currently I’ve a piece of prose that is and must be adjective laden simply because of the nature of the piece. I’m starting to wonder if I should let go and flower away then trim to shape?

            What is prose with out poetry? What is poetry without prose? Ummm...file it under creative writing.
  • Ian
    Ian
    offline 0

    Re: Critique please.

    Wed, May 16, 2007 - 10:44 PM
    1) The lack of tonal qualities. This piece lacks consonance, assonance, alliteration, etc.
    Free verse does not mean tone-deaf.

    2) To paraphrase Mill, Eloquence is heard; poetry is overheard. Since this speaker is addressing a particular individual, it is most likely (unconsciously) heard as a monologue.

    3) Too many lines are simply there to advance the plot. Poetry has no concerns with plot.

    4) This work requires "suspension of disbelief". The reader is required to assume that no one in the "we" has been to the house before. That the "we" have access to the house (without breaking and entering). That no one in the "we" would recognize that it is wrong house once entering. Fiction, not poetry, uses SoD.

    5) The event is cliche.
  • Re: Critique please.

    Thu, May 17, 2007 - 11:39 AM
    I thought this was hilarious. The theme was unique and one that I've never encountered before. *Still chuckling over "we went to the wrong house" - this is priceless!* Structurally, it was pleasing. I like "symmetry." "On your mark, get set, go!" felt like an angle of repose for this piece, the first half in front of it balancing the second half after it. Well done!

    Ther - nomizo pou doulevei.

Recent topics in "Creative Writing Critique"