This is my first posting to the group.
I wrote a version of this recently that was too dry and analytical. This is a more lyrical and stylized version of the same true story. I feel like it is close, but a little bit... umm... disjointed? I think I might be too close to it, so I am putting it out there for comment and criticism.
Thank you in advance!
- CJ
--------------------------------
Eastern Wind
by Christian "CJ" Jacobsen
Night time drops fast and hard in the Balkan winter. The dull light of the day gives up by early afternoon, and night comes down like a concrete block.
During the day, the wind is formed in the soft and sophisticated winter of European skiers. Layers keep you warm and deflect this western winter coming down from the forests and mountains of northern Italy and Austria.
Then you shiver. Look up from what you are doing. Check behind you. Something is different. Something has changed.
The wind. It comes from due east now… from the steppes it blows across the Ukraine, Romania, Bulgaria. Unhindered, the wind gathers the cold as it sweeps across the fallow plains and frozen waterways of eastern Hungary and Serbia. You feel the change instantly. Through your layers the cold needles from the east freeze your skin and chill your bones.
It is dark. The eastern cold is here. This is a night when families gather round a fire that never seems to be quite big enough, quite bright enough, or quite warm enough.
I am somewhere in Bosnia i Herzegovina, also known as BiH, or just Bosnia. I am driving a large delivery truck down a small two-lane road. At irregular intervals my headlights illuminate uninhabited villages that still show prominent evidence of the battles fought here recently. More often than not, the village or town is mostly inhabited, with only the most badly damaged homes and businesses still abandoned.
The heater in the truck is trying valiantly but I still have on my layers, my jacket, my gloves.
This is a deeply creepy part of the world. In daylight, the path the Yugoslav army took through these idyllic villages is obvious. Huge gaping holes in the walls of homes indicate the tanks came from the east. Deep scars from machine guns ring bedroom windows, the only testament to some local villager who stood their ground for a few minutes before being crushed under the onslaught of the Yugoslav army. The light of the day illuminates the depressions in the ground where the tanks rolled and a path of young trees among old growth forest indicates where the army came through the woods.
At night, the scene changes. I catch brief glimpses as the headlights illuminate details of the roadside destruction. A peek into an abandoned living room through a hole left by a tank round. Splintered door frames sticking up out of the rubble of a demolished home. Bullet holes tracing an upward arc along a wall.
The single most disturbing thing to see is just as night falls. The countryside is littered with cemeteries, some official, next to a church, and others stand alone in fields or at the edges of villages, cemeteries built according to need. Some with graves in neat rows, others more hastily built.
In every one of these cemeteries, families and friends of the deceased come out every night and light a candle in front of the grave markers. One a simple stone marker capped with the crescent moon and star of Islam. Another with the Star of David. Another with a cross. And another with the double-bar cross of the Serbian Orthodox church. All these graves, side by side, most with a single candle inside of a red glass candleholder like you would expect to find on the table at some kitsch Italian restaurant.
Each glass globe shields the flame from the wind and casts an eerie red glow onto the grave marker.
Coming around a bend in the utter darkness of a Balkan winter, and seeing a clearing in the trees with hundreds of these red flickering tombstones is a sight that will forever cause a tightening of stomach and shoulders. As I write this, more than five years after the experience, goose-bumps rise on my arms.
The sight itself is enough to leave an indelible impression. But as they say: it’s the thought that counts.
Consider this: Every day, someone goes out there and lights a candle at one or more of these graves. Every day, that person plans their trip to the cemetery. Every day, that person checks if they have a candle for tonight, or if they need to go by the shop on the way home from work. Every day, that person kneels in front of the grave of a friend, family member, loved one, and remembers them. Their life. Their vibrancy. Their times together that impels this person to make their daily pilgrimage to this grave.
During that Balkan winter the chill needles of the eastern wind, the wind from the steppes, the wind like icy concrete, cold and gritty on your cheek, the wind from the Ukraine that has been gathering the cold like a mother gathers a frightened child to her breast, the wind blows across the remains of the Balkans. The cold stones scream of the life they represent. Scream to the deaf wind.
And another person kneels down, lights a candle for the dead.
-------------------------------
I wrote a version of this recently that was too dry and analytical. This is a more lyrical and stylized version of the same true story. I feel like it is close, but a little bit... umm... disjointed? I think I might be too close to it, so I am putting it out there for comment and criticism.
Thank you in advance!
- CJ
--------------------------------
Eastern Wind
by Christian "CJ" Jacobsen
Night time drops fast and hard in the Balkan winter. The dull light of the day gives up by early afternoon, and night comes down like a concrete block.
During the day, the wind is formed in the soft and sophisticated winter of European skiers. Layers keep you warm and deflect this western winter coming down from the forests and mountains of northern Italy and Austria.
Then you shiver. Look up from what you are doing. Check behind you. Something is different. Something has changed.
The wind. It comes from due east now… from the steppes it blows across the Ukraine, Romania, Bulgaria. Unhindered, the wind gathers the cold as it sweeps across the fallow plains and frozen waterways of eastern Hungary and Serbia. You feel the change instantly. Through your layers the cold needles from the east freeze your skin and chill your bones.
It is dark. The eastern cold is here. This is a night when families gather round a fire that never seems to be quite big enough, quite bright enough, or quite warm enough.
I am somewhere in Bosnia i Herzegovina, also known as BiH, or just Bosnia. I am driving a large delivery truck down a small two-lane road. At irregular intervals my headlights illuminate uninhabited villages that still show prominent evidence of the battles fought here recently. More often than not, the village or town is mostly inhabited, with only the most badly damaged homes and businesses still abandoned.
The heater in the truck is trying valiantly but I still have on my layers, my jacket, my gloves.
This is a deeply creepy part of the world. In daylight, the path the Yugoslav army took through these idyllic villages is obvious. Huge gaping holes in the walls of homes indicate the tanks came from the east. Deep scars from machine guns ring bedroom windows, the only testament to some local villager who stood their ground for a few minutes before being crushed under the onslaught of the Yugoslav army. The light of the day illuminates the depressions in the ground where the tanks rolled and a path of young trees among old growth forest indicates where the army came through the woods.
At night, the scene changes. I catch brief glimpses as the headlights illuminate details of the roadside destruction. A peek into an abandoned living room through a hole left by a tank round. Splintered door frames sticking up out of the rubble of a demolished home. Bullet holes tracing an upward arc along a wall.
The single most disturbing thing to see is just as night falls. The countryside is littered with cemeteries, some official, next to a church, and others stand alone in fields or at the edges of villages, cemeteries built according to need. Some with graves in neat rows, others more hastily built.
In every one of these cemeteries, families and friends of the deceased come out every night and light a candle in front of the grave markers. One a simple stone marker capped with the crescent moon and star of Islam. Another with the Star of David. Another with a cross. And another with the double-bar cross of the Serbian Orthodox church. All these graves, side by side, most with a single candle inside of a red glass candleholder like you would expect to find on the table at some kitsch Italian restaurant.
Each glass globe shields the flame from the wind and casts an eerie red glow onto the grave marker.
Coming around a bend in the utter darkness of a Balkan winter, and seeing a clearing in the trees with hundreds of these red flickering tombstones is a sight that will forever cause a tightening of stomach and shoulders. As I write this, more than five years after the experience, goose-bumps rise on my arms.
The sight itself is enough to leave an indelible impression. But as they say: it’s the thought that counts.
Consider this: Every day, someone goes out there and lights a candle at one or more of these graves. Every day, that person plans their trip to the cemetery. Every day, that person checks if they have a candle for tonight, or if they need to go by the shop on the way home from work. Every day, that person kneels in front of the grave of a friend, family member, loved one, and remembers them. Their life. Their vibrancy. Their times together that impels this person to make their daily pilgrimage to this grave.
During that Balkan winter the chill needles of the eastern wind, the wind from the steppes, the wind like icy concrete, cold and gritty on your cheek, the wind from the Ukraine that has been gathering the cold like a mother gathers a frightened child to her breast, the wind blows across the remains of the Balkans. The cold stones scream of the life they represent. Scream to the deaf wind.
And another person kneels down, lights a candle for the dead.
-------------------------------
-
Re: Creative nonfiction for critique please
Tue, June 5, 2007 - 12:03 AMhi there
(take this lightly for sure)
i liked the beggining as far as the comparison from the western european winter to the eastern winter and i think you should tie it back to the end of the story.
i also think the first line is disjointed but good, i would arange it differently.....such as :
As the day gives up the night comes down like a concrete block, hard and fast, in the Balkin winter
: or something of that sort
also i dont like the word 'creepy' for some reason. for me it would sound better if "This is a deep part of the world" or dark or heavy
let me know if this helps at all
thanks
robert
-
Re: Creative nonfiction for critique please
Tue, June 5, 2007 - 9:41 AMMore a mood piece than actual story line, but you've done well with setting a time and place. I like it Bucky, keep up the writing.
-
Re: Creative nonfiction for critique please
Tue, June 5, 2007 - 11:28 AMYou were right when you said this piece is more on the "lyrical and stylized" side.
Your descriptions were very vivid and haunting. I love it!
But I have to agree with Steve. There's not much of a storyline going on. And what you have here does have a lot of potential. Maybe if you can give a little more background about yourself, why you are in Bosnia, why you're driving down that path. Give a little more of your thoughts and how you changed as person after crossing paths with such as scene. Then maybe a story will emerge out of it.
It's a great piece. You have the writing part down. You just need a story. -
-
Re: Creative nonfiction for critique please
Tue, June 5, 2007 - 12:23 PMAgreed. The prose in of itself is solid. Brilliant. Evocative.
and honestly I wouldn't worry so much about trying to 'craft' this into a story. give it some time. often trying to superimpose some sort of 'plot' for the sake of having a 'plot' can muck things up. but that said, I agree with Paulina--maybe you could insert a flashback to create some backstory/context for the reader.
(this reminds me of hearing an old radio piece of an old man who used to play his violin in a mortar shell crater in Serajevo. what sustained the story was simply the quiet, personal touch--the personal depiction of this man who was doing what he could, in his own way, to make something beautiful in the midst of chaos.)
random ideas-- follow someone who is placing a candle? perhaps there is a story from your experience that you can add to this/ sort of a layer thing. But really the decision lies with you.
If you want to convert it to fiction -- to tell the truth by telling a lie -- don't be afraid to try. But by all means--I think at this point with the story and your reflections, keep it personal and keep things as true as possible. Distorting things for the sake of 'literary standing' can have serious costs when it comes to this topic.
You may write some things that you regret writing. But at this point, I think your story is important enough to really explore and develop. Trust in your abilities, (you *are* really good) write hard, but be ready to forgive yourself for not writing perfection. This stuff has nothing to do with perfection/craft/form. Let that happen later. Ideally I'd recommend that you really do a sort of writing exorcism and really crank out a lot of material. details. people. smells. etc. From that mass of material, give it some time, then start crafting.
Just remember to go easy on yourself. Some things can take years to work out. Writing (and the writing process) can help, but just remember--really it's just a tool of sorts. Maybe let the writing be roadmarkers of a sort... anyhow--cheers. sorry to blab your ear off--but good stuff. really good. keep at it. -
-
Re: Creative nonfiction for critique please
Tue, June 5, 2007 - 1:27 PMThank you, please may I have another?
-
Re: Creative nonfiction for critique please
Tue, June 5, 2007 - 9:37 PMWow! So much wonderful feedback from everyone... I feel energized from the great input you all have given me!
Pedro (and Paulina, and, and...) all suggested I contextualize the store more, or do more of a backstory. Actually, this is something I was specifically trying to avoid. Here's why: One of the things I experienced when I moved back to the US was that people zoned out and stopped listening when I told stories like this to them. They had no frame of reference for it, so they had a hard time getting a hold on it, or paying attention to it.
This piece is my first attempt at writing something that anyone could put themselves in to, simply because the narrator is sketched as a light grey outline... it could be anyone. Male, female, American, French, Cambodian, idealistic young backpacker, or jaded businessman. The idea was to tell the story in such a way that if anyone read it out loud, the listeners would believe that person was telling their own story. My hope is then the reader could believe themselves in such a situation, and get a visceral reaction from it.
For me, the story line is almost like the movie "Barfly"... In Barfly the camera rolls in the door of a bar, right in the middle of a conversation. It then follows the lead character for 3 days, and then - in the middle of another conversation in the same bar, the camera backs out the door, and the movie ends. We have experienced a snippet of Henry Chinaski's life, and that is all the story there is.
I had hoped that the eastern wind bookended the story, and gave this snippet of my memory some visceral context in which the reader could feel the cold... the cold of the wind, the cold of the winter, the cold of the night, and the cold of the dead.
All the feedback I have received has helped me to see the story with fresh eyes... I'm off to do a rewrite of it now.
Thank you all! -
-
Re: Creative nonfiction for critique please
Thu, June 7, 2007 - 2:33 PM>One of the things I experienced when I moved back to the US was that people zoned out and stopped listening when I told stories like this to them. They had no frame of reference for it, so they had a hard time getting a hold on it, or paying attention to it.
hehe that's how it is. People's eyes glaze over when I talk about my stuff too. UNLESS I start w/ guns and death. Then it becomes "poignant" or some sort of shit. But my mumsie told me something very very valuable once: "No one wants to hear about your trip."
simple fact of life. which sadly, is why we need things like 'hooks'
good luck, have fun! (hehe)
-
-
-
-
Rewritten
Wed, June 13, 2007 - 9:16 PMI have made some major edits to the previous version of this piece. I'd like to see if any of you who reviewed it before have any new input on this....
Thanks!
- CJ
--------------------------
Night time drops fast and hard in the Balkan winter. A cold, concrete block, the night snuffs out the dim, lifeless light of day. One minute it is simply dreary. The next it is dark, with a hard cold that leans on you like a crumbling wall.
During the day, the wind is formed in the soft and sophisticated winter of European skiers. Layers keep you warm and deflect this western winter coming down from the forests and mountains of northern Italy and Austria.
Then you shiver. Look up. Check behind you. Something is different. Something has changed.
It’s the wind. It comes from due east now… from the ancient steppes it blows across the Ukraine, Romania, Bulgaria. Unhindered, the wind gathers the cold as it sweeps across the fallow plains and frozen waterways of eastern Hungary and Serbia. Cold needles from the east penetrate your winter layers, freeze your skin and chill your bones.
The eastern cold is here. This is a night when families huddle round a fire that never seems to be quite big enough, quite bright enough, or quite warm enough.
I am somewhere in Bosnia i Herzegovina, also known as BiH, or just Bosnia, driving down a small two-lane road. At irregular intervals my headlights illuminate uninhabited villages that still show prominent evidence of the battles fought here recently. More often than not, the village or town is inhabited, with only the most badly damaged homes and businesses still abandoned. Other villages are modern ghost towns.
Even with the windows up, the heater tries valiantly but I still need my layers, my jacket, my gloves.
This is a part of the world where countless generations of hard-fought history lie close below the surface. In daylight, the path the Yugoslav army took through these idyllic villages is obvious. The depressions in the fertile soil left by tank treads and trucks. A path of young trees striping through old growth forest indicates where the army broke through the woods. Gaping holes in the eastern walls of homes indicate where the tanks came from. Deep scars from machine guns ring bedroom windows, the only testament to some local villager who stood their ground for a few desperate minutes.
The scene becomes darker and more sinister in the Balkan night. I catch brief glimpses as the headlights illuminate details of the roadside destruction. A peek into an abandoned living room through a hole left by a tank. Splintered door frames stick out of the rubble of a demolished home. Bullet holes trace an upward arc along a wall. These are only the most recent marks of history on this well-traveled path between Europe and Asia.
The nightfall brings the single most disturbing thing to see. This countryside is littered with cemeteries. Some official, next to a church, and others stand alone in fields or at the edges of villages; cemeteries built according to need. Some with graves in neat rows, others hastily dug or jammed in tight along a bend in the road.
In each of these cemeteries, families and friends of the deceased come out every night and light a candle in front of the grave markers. One stone marker capped with the crescent moon and star of Islam. Another with the Star of David. Another with a cross. And others with the double-bar cross of the Serbian Orthodox church. All these graves, side by side, and most of them illuminated by a single candle.
Each candle is shielded from the wind with a red glass globe like you find on the table of a cheap Italian restaurant. The flame casts an eerie flickering red glow onto the grave marker.
Coming around a bend in the road in the utter darkness of a Balkan winter, and seeing a clearing in the trees with hundreds of these red flickering tombstones is a memory that will forever cause a tightening in my stomach and shoulders. As I write this, more than five years after the experience, goose-bumps rise on my arms.
The sight itself is enough to leave an indelible impression… but when you think about it, there is more. Much more.
Every day, people go out there and light candles at these graves. Every day, they plan their trip to the cemetery. Every day, they check if they have a candles for tonight, or if they need to go by the shop on the way home from work. Every day, these people kneel in front of the grave of a friend, family member, loved one, and remember them. Their life. Their vibrancy. Their times together. It impels these people to make their daily pilgrimage to the graves.
During that Balkan winter the chill needles of the eastern wind, the wind from the steppes, the wind like icy concrete, cold and gritty on your cheek, the wind from the Ukraine that has been gathering the cold like a mother gathers a frightened child to her breast, the wind blows across the memories in the Balkans. The cold headstones and their religious ornaments scream of the death they represent. Scream to the deaf wind.
And another person kneels down, lighting a candle for the dead.
----------------- -
-
Re: Rewritten
Mon, July 2, 2007 - 4:27 PMWell, actually, what I wanted was another piece.
But ok. Just off the bat, I like the way you've organized the paragraphs a lot better this time.
You could drop sentence 6 and it would all be the same to me.
And maybe try some contractions to make it seem more casual.
And:
Coming around a bend in the road in the utter darkness of a Balkan winter, and seeing a clearing in the trees with hundreds of these red flickering tombstones is a memory that will forever cause a tightening in my stomach and shoulders.
Could be: "a memory that still causes"
-
-
Re: Creative nonfiction for critique please
Sun, October 28, 2007 - 9:39 AMhi. my first posting on this site. havent even set up my profile yet. but i stumbled by this tribe and will post soon. in the mean time.
great mood piece. i could see the lights and feel the cold. i really liked the comparisons you made between the weather and concrete. it really brought the unpleasantness of the place out for me. the only real problem i had with the peice was "Consider this: ". that one little phrase pulled me right out of the story. suddenly instead of being guided through that cold dark wasteland where i swore i could see the fading light of the small and distant sun shine its final lights through the bullet holes of ruined homes and the shadows of wraith like silouettes of people moving about in the dark between buildings, i was being preached to. a good story (this story) does not need to step outside of its form to try to make a point. ive allready considered everything youv'e talked about, and as i have stated above, a few other things you did not intend. every good story and apreciative reader will interact this way. i would loose the "Consider this: " and re write that paragraph as a part of the story, not an outside. it will be less pretentious, and gain emotional heft. i would also move it up a little. and consider loosing "The sight itself is enough to leave an indelible impression. But as they say: it’s the thought that counts." we know they dont mean to be spooky.
your story is memorable and will probably bounce around in my head for the rest of the day.
looking forward to more of your work.
brandon